Judgment handed down in Hadley v Przybylo

News

15/03/2024

The Court of Appeal has decided that the Claimant’s solicitors’ costs of attending rehabilitation case management meetings are recoverable as costs of an action, in principle, but has not given solicitors carte-blanche to expect to be paid to attend each and every meeting.

The matter came before the Court in Hadley v Przybylo [2024] EWCA Civ 250.  In the case, the claimant had been catastrophically injured in a road traffic collision, and a comprehensive rehabilitation package put in place.  The Claimant’s and, to a lesser extent Defendant’s, solicitors attended case management meetings.  Proceedings were issued and came before Master McCloud for a Costs and Case Management Conference.  In the ‘Issues / Statements of Case’ phase, the Claimant’s solicitors have included both incurred and future estimated costs for attending case management meetings.  On challenge from the Defendant, the Master concluded that the costs were not recoverable in principle on the basis that they were ‘inherently non-progressive’, being costs that did not progress the litigation.

In a leapfrog appeal, the Court of Appeal overturned that conclusion.  It held that the test of whether a legal cost is recoverable inter-parties remains that as stated in In re Gibson’s Settlement Trusts [1981] Ch 179 at 184F-G.  To be recoverable, the cost must relate to something which (i) proved of use and service in the action; (ii) was relevant to an issue; and (iii) was attributed to the defendant’s conduct.  Coulson LJ summarised these tests as: (i) utility, (ii) relevance and (iii) attributability.  The Court of Appeal held that attendance at case management meetings satisfied that test and, as a result, the costs associated with that attendance were recoverable in principle.

However, the Court went to some lengths to point out that this did not mean that the costs of attending each and every case management meeting could be recovered.  It acknowledged that it was important that the Claimant’s solicitors keep an appropriate eye on the rehabilitation plans (and, so, avoid a reduction in the claim for the costs of that rehabilitation if it is found to have been of poor quality or inadequate – as occurred in Loughlin v Singh & Ors [2013] EWHC 1641).  But held that, whether the cost of any specific attendance was recoverable was a matter of fact, to be determined by considering whether the attendance in question satisfied the test of recoverability in In re Gibson’s Settlement Trusts.  In addition, the Court acknowledged that the costs must always be reasonable and proportionate to be recoverable.  In the case, the Claimant’s claim for costs for attendance at case management meetings was more than £130,000.  It is fair to say that the Court raised more than just a judicial eyebrow at that sum. 

In short, then, the costs of attending case management meetings can be recovered in principle, but, to be recoverable, the solicitor’s attendance needs to have some utility and relevance to the progress of the case, and be as a result of the injury caused to the Claimant.  In addition, the costs must be reasonable and proportionate to the amount at stake and issues in the case.

Featured Counsel

Simon Brindle

Call 1998

Latest News & Events

Catherine Atkinson and Jake Richards successful in General Election

Congratulations to both Catherine Atkinson and Jake Richards who were elected as Members of Parliament in last week’s General Election. Catherine was elected in Derby North and Jake was elected in Rother Valley. We wish them both well in their new positions.

Deka Chambers shortlisted in Legal 500 Bar Awards 2024

Huge congratulations to our teams and individuals who have been shortlisted in the Legal 500 Bar Awards 2024: Thanks, as always, to our clients who provided feedback during the research process, and to the Legal 500 research teams. The Awards ceremony takes place on 25th…

Conference: Surgery in Clinical Negligence Claims

Join us at Glaziers Hall on Thursday, 10th October for an afternoon of presentations on the topic of surgery. Our expert speakers, along with members of Deka Chambers’ clinical negligence team, will provide a range of talks focusing on surgical claims.  Three acclaimed medical experts will be…

Subscribe to our mailing list

Deka Chambers: 5 Norwich Street, London EC4A 1DR

© Deka Chambers 2024

Search

Portfolio Builder

Select the expertise that you would like to download or add to the portfolio

Download    Add to portfolio   
Portfolio
Title Type CV Email

Remove All

Download


Click here to share this shortlist.
(It will expire after 30 days.)