A Local Authority v EF & Ors [2023] EWFC 178



Laura Hibberd acted for the children through their Guardian throughout care proceedings in this case. Laura was instructed by Gemma Hodder at Miles and Partners.

The local authority initially commenced proceedings due to concerns that the mother was exaggerating the children’s needs and perceived they had disabilities which professionals had not corroborated. The father had made a separate Child Arrangements Application, having not seen his children for several years. Within those proceedings the mother had made very serious allegations of physical and sexual abuse. At the final hearing the court conducted a fact-finding exercise and found her allegations to be false and malicious.

The case was characterised by complaints from the mother, which was a significant feature in the final hearing. It made it very hard for professionals to help the family and undertake important work with the children. Even following the children’s removal from their mother’s care during proceedings, the concerns escalated after tracking devices and 4 mobile phone handsets were found in one of the child’s school uniform, the court held the mother had encouraged, enabled or instructed the child to obtain these and conceal them from professionals.

At the final hearing, the court accepted the case put on behalf of the Guardian that several of the complaints were made by the mother pretending to be her oldest child. The court found the mother made a number of unreasonable and excessive complaints. The judgment requires the mother, whenever she makes a future complaint, to disclose that she makes unjustified complaints against professionals to manipulate, frighten and browbeat them to do what she wants.  

The court also agreed with the Guardian’s request, supported by the Local Authority, for non-molestation orders to continue for the children and s91(14) orders to be made.

Read the full judgment here.

Featured Counsel

Laura Hibberd

Call 2013

Latest News & Events

Consultation Paper Seeks Reform of Limitation Law in Child Sexual Abuse Cases

The Ministry of Justice has released a consultation paper seeking views on potential reforms to the law of limitation in child sexual abuse cases in England and Wales. Under the current law, child sexual abuse cases in civil courts are subject to the same three-year…

The Dekagram: 20th May 2024

We trust that our readers have been enjoying the Spring sunshine; the team have spent their time in the sun wisely, reading cases so you don’t have to. First we noted a decision which considers the interplay between English and Scottish guardianship; secondly we read…

The Dekagram: 13th May 2024

Last week brought the news that the Australian airline Qantas and the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission have agreed to resolve their dispute over cancelled flights by asking the court to impose a $100 million fine, together with an undertaking by the airline to pay…

Subscribe to our mailing list

Deka Chambers: 5 Norwich Street, London EC4A 1DR

© Deka Chambers 2024


Portfolio Builder

Select the expertise that you would like to download or add to the portfolio

Download    Add to portfolio   
Title Type CV Email

Remove All


Click here to share this shortlist.
(It will expire after 30 days.)