Edwin Buckett wins permission from the Court of Appeal to challenge a judgment where deceit is admitted in earlier proceedings

News

30/01/2015

On the 30th January 2015, a reserved judgment of a three Judge Court of Appeal granted the Appellant, in Bishop-v-Chhokar, the right to appeal an order where the Respondent subsequently admitted lying when giving evidence in earlier civil proceedings. The lies came to light in a second action between the same parties when the Respondent was giving evidence.

The question for the Court was whether the jurisdiction under CPR 52.17 should be exercised in a case to allow the original judgment to be challenged on appeal out of time or, whether a fresh action for fraud should be brought against the Respondent.

To qualify for the CPR 52.17 jurisdiction, the Appellant needed to show, amongst other things, that there was no other ‘effective remedy’. Aikens LJ, concluded that there must be ‘some doubt’ whether the County Court had jurisdiction to determine a free-standing claim to set aside a previous decision of the County Court said to have been obtained by fraud.

In addition, he concluded that it was “very much open to doubt” that the High Court had the procedural power to set aside or rescind a judgment alleged to have been obtained by fraud in a lower Court.

The full appeal will be listed later this year and the Court of Appeal is expected to give guidance on how an aggrieved litigant or insurer might proceed where deceit is exposed and an earlier judgment obtained which a party wishes to be challenge.

Edwin appeared for the successful Appellant instructed by Bark & Co, London EC4.

Featured Counsel

Edwin Buckett

Call 1988

Latest News & Events

Lipton and Another v BA Cityflyer Limited [2024] UKSC 24: Denied Boarding, and Brexit Rules of Engagement

In a recent decision the Supreme Court gave guidance as to the interpretation of Regulation (EC) 261/2004 (almost universally – but not in the Supreme Court – known as ‘the Denied Boarding Regulation’), and in doing so, set out a handy guide for practitioners on…

The Dekagram: 15th July 2024

This week we examine the perils inherent in issuing proceedings at the last minute, especially when dealing with the e-filing system implemented in order to make all of our lives easier. As always, the team’s advice is: don’t do it, it’ll end in tears. And…

Catherine Atkinson and Jake Richards successful in General Election

Congratulations to both Catherine Atkinson and Jake Richards who were elected as Members of Parliament in last week’s General Election. Catherine was elected in Derby North and Jake was elected in Rother Valley. We wish them both well in their new positions.

Subscribe to our mailing list

Deka Chambers: 5 Norwich Street, London EC4A 1DR

© Deka Chambers 2024

Search

Portfolio Builder

Select the expertise that you would like to download or add to the portfolio

Download    Add to portfolio   
Portfolio
Title Type CV Email

Remove All

Download


Click here to share this shortlist.
(It will expire after 30 days.)