Much of children law involves the exploration of the facts relating to the child’s care and welfare, often coloured by the complex relationship dynamics between the adult protagonists. Occasionally, however, the facts which need to be established can be more fundamental.
In John v Jane [2026] EWHC 415 (Fam), Judd J had to decide a preliminary factual issue in a private law children application that went to the heart of the case: did the two children exist at all?
No summary can really do justice to this “most extraordinary case”. To save the reader from skipping to the end I will say at the outset that the court found that the children did not exist.
John issued an application to ascertain the whereabouts of two children that he told the court he had fathered during his relationship with Jane. He made no claim to have ever met the children. Jane’s response to the application was that the children had never been born. She accepted that she had told John that she had been pregnant and that she had communicated the births of the children and shared information and photographs. Her positive case was that this was all an elaborate deception. John did not accept that he had been deceived. He and his mother said that they had both seen Jane heavily pregnant. He told the court that he had been providing financial support to Jane for the children.
How does one go about proving the existence of children that they have never met? In this case the court allowed applications for disclosure of medical records, bank statements and passport information. Information was sought from the police and local authorities and the birth registry. None of this provided clear evidence of the existence of the children. The court ordered expert examination of an ultrasound image and directed a forensic examination of Jane’s phone. Witness summonses were made in respect of Jane’s adult children.
On the other hand, how does one respond to such an application, both seeking to prove a negative and relying on their own sustained dishonesty? Jane’s vulnerability was in evidence before the court. A psychiatric assessment concluded that she had suffered from lifelong depression and anxiety alongside complex PTSD. She told the court that she had lied to John and repeated this to other people. She explained that the photographs of the children that she had sent had been taken from the social media account of a person she followed whose children were of a similar age to the children that she had invented. In relation to evidence that she had appeared visibly pregnant Jane explained that she had always been somewhat on the large side.
The court heard evidence from John, his mother, his friend, Jane and two of her adult children. The Judge found that John, his mother and his friend were entirely genuine in the evidence they gave. The Judge’s observations as to the evidence from Jane and her children were less reassuring as to their reliability.
The Judge accepted that John and his mother believed that Jane was pregnant going so far as to conclude that, in all the circumstances of the deceit that it was wholly plausible that they were convinced that she was pregnant when she was not. The witnesses whose evidence supported John’s case were honest but ultimately mistaken.
Despite the doubts about her reliability, and applying the well-known direction in Lucas, the court accepted that Jane’s previous deception of John and others did not undermine her evidence on the central issue because of the factual matrix before the court. In the absence of any evidence to confirm the existence of the children beyond what Jane had previously provided to John, the Judge ultimately accepted that Jane’s account to the court was true. The children did not exist.
Edward Lamb KC and Kate Lamont were instructed on behalf of the Respondent by Carolina Marín Pedreño and Kandice Phillips of Dawson Cornwell.
Join Deka Chambers barrister and mediator Laura Elfield and Tessa Herman, an experienced personal injury solicitor and mediator for a whistle stop tour on mediation. Laura and Tessa, both NHS Panel Mediators, will look at when and why to opt for mediation, explore the different forms of mediation, give tips on getting…
We are thrilled that Andrew Warnock KC has been awarded Personal Injury Silk of the Year and Deka Chambers Personal Injury Set of the Year at the Chambers UK Bar Awards at a ceremony on Thursday evening 12 November. In the latest Chambers UK Bar…
by Beatrice Fatungase A recent Family Court judgment serves as a stark reminder on the use of artificial intelligence, and that those who rely on it will remain accountable for the result. In Cornwall Council v M and F [2026] EWFC 306, HHJ Flexman criticised…
Deka Chambers: 5 Norwich Street, London EC4A 1DR