Max Melsa successfully obtains judgment for Claimant following Defendant raising automatism

News

04/04/2022

Max Melsa represented the Claimant in a claim for personal injury within which the Defendant raised the unusual defence of automatism. 

The defence, which requires the Defendant to show on the balance of probabilities that the Defendant’s actions were wholly involuntary, was raised following a road traffic accident that occurred in September 2017. 

Max successfully argued for the Court to follow the case of Green v Haynes [2014] EWHC 4297 (QB) which sets out the high bar required for the Court to allow such a defence. It was also argued that the medical evidence provided by the Defendant was insufficient. 

Judge ruled that the Defendant had failed to prove, on balance, that there was no alternative explanation other than that the Defendant had suffered a cardiogenic syncope.

The Court of Appeal case of Dunnage v Randall [2015] EWCA Civ 673 was also considered.

Max was instructed by Adrian McGurk of Ralli Solicitors.

Featured Counsel

Max Melsa

Call 2015

Latest News & Events

The Dekagram: 8th July 2025

In the week the Hague Convention came into force, whilst the domestic courts heard an important appeal on Covid refund claims, Anirudh Mandagere and Tom Collins bring us all the latest news both internationally and nationally. And as always, members of Deka Chambers are at…

Tom Little KC and James Thacker KC provide training to the CPS Homicide Unit

On 1 July, chambers was delighted to welcome leaders and members of the CPS Homicide Unit for a training and social evening. First Senior Treasury Counsel and Joint Head of Chambers Tom Little KC, was able to draw upon his experience of prosecuting some of…

The Dekagram: 30th June 2025

This week Julia Brechtelsbauer grapples with the continuing issues around taking evidence from abroad, and examines a case which illustrates well the problems, both legal and practical, that can arise when dealing with witnesses located in another jurisdiction. Meanwhile, Andrew Spencer asks whether UK law…

© Deka Chambers 2025

Search

Portfolio Builder

Select the expertise that you would like to download or add to the portfolio

Download    Add to portfolio   
Portfolio
Title Type CV Email

Remove All

Download


Click here to share this shortlist.
(It will expire after 30 days.)