On 23rd June 2021, at the Oxford Magistrates’ Court, one of the UK’s leading egg packing companies pleaded guilty to nine charges under the Eggs and Chicks (England) Regulations 2009. The offences each concerned failure to comply with provisions relating to the quality and marketing of eggs set out in Commission Regulation (EC) 589/2008.
Egg marketing inspectors attended Noble Foods Ltd’s packing centre in Standlake near Witney on several occasions between July 2019 and March 2020. Of 62 batches of eggs tested, 28 did not meet quality standards. The failure rates were between 6.7% and 14.4%, each in excess of the 5% tolerance permitted by the Community Regulation.
The company accepted the failings but argued that it had made significant changes since the dates in question. District Judge Rana imposed a fine of £5,300 on each of the nine offences, to a total of £47,700. The court also directed payment of a victim surcharge and costs.
Local news coverage can be found here.
The case was prosecuted by William Dean, who was instructed by Simon Tunnicliffe of the CPS’s Mersey Cheshire Fraud Unit.
This week Thomas Yarrow revisits the vexed question of the use of artificial intelligence in legal research – and our intrepid reporter finds that it’s not all it’s cracked up to be. In fact the experience led him to such depths of despair that he…
This week Ben Rodgers relays two tales from the coalface, both relating to applications to resile from admissions. Readers will be interested to know that in both cases the court applied the balance of prejudice test with the result that the defendants’ applications were refused….
This week Conor Kennedy considers a novel point of construction in relation to challenging service of claim forms; the headline is that defendants must take steps to mount a jurisdictional challenge within the tight deadlines provided for in the CPR, but Conor asks whether this…
Deka Chambers: 5 Norwich Street, London EC4A 1DR