QOCS and mixed claims



  1. If Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562 was argued today, would Ms Donoghue have had QOCS protection? Not if she had been claiming for the cost of another bottle of ginger beer, as well as damages for gastro-enteritis, according to an “undoubtedly memorable” submission made to the Court of Appeal in Andrea Brown v (1) Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis (2) The Chief Constable of Greater Manchester Police (The Equality and Human Rights Commission Intervening) [2019] EWCA Civ 1724.
  2. Brown is the first time that the Court of Appeal has grappled with the application of the QOCS regime to “mixed” claims, (i.e. where a claimant claims damages for personal injury and in the same proceedings also claims non-personal injury damages or other relief). Lord Faulks QC of 1 Chancery Lane was Leading Counsel for the successful respondent.
  3. In my article I examine the Court of Appeal’s conclusion that a mixed claim does not benefit from automatic QOCS protection, and argue that the guidance it has given as to when a court should disapply QOCS in mixed cases is wrong.
  4. The short answer to the question about Ms Donoghue, incidentally, is that she could not have claimed the cost of another bottle of ginger beer. She did not buy the first one. If she had, she could have sued in contract rather than tort. Her case would have never reached the House of Lords, and she would have been unknown to generations of lawyers.

Latest News & Events

The Dekagram: 15th July 2024

This week we examine the perils inherent in issuing proceedings at the last minute, especially when dealing with the e-filing system implemented in order to make all of our lives easier. As always, the team’s advice is: don’t do it, it’ll end in tears. And…

Catherine Atkinson and Jake Richards successful in General Election

Congratulations to both Catherine Atkinson and Jake Richards who were elected as Members of Parliament in last week’s General Election. Catherine was elected in Derby North and Jake was elected in Rother Valley. We wish them both well in their new positions.

Deka Chambers shortlisted in Legal 500 Bar Awards 2024

Huge congratulations to our teams and individuals who have been shortlisted in the Legal 500 Bar Awards 2024: Thanks, as always, to our clients who provided feedback during the research process, and to the Legal 500 research teams. The Awards ceremony takes place on 25th…

Subscribe to our mailing list

Deka Chambers: 5 Norwich Street, London EC4A 1DR

© Deka Chambers 2024


Portfolio Builder

Select the expertise that you would like to download or add to the portfolio

Download    Add to portfolio   
Title Type CV Email

Remove All


Click here to share this shortlist.
(It will expire after 30 days.)