12/04/2019
Presented at the PEOPIL Conference, May 2019.
Mrs X and her husband booked a 14 night all-inclusive package holiday to Sri Lanka. In the early hours of 17 July 2010 Mrs X made her way on foot (alone) from the Hotel room that she shared with her husband towards the Hotel reception. On her way she encountered someone that she had briefly met earlier the same evening: a uniform-wearing employee of the Hotel. The employee (an electrician in the Hotel maintenance department) informed Mrs X that he knew a faster way to reception and that she should follow him. They entered an engineering room at the Hotel where the employee raped Mrs X. Shortly thereafter, she reported the assault to her husband (who had been looking for her) and to the management of the Hotel.
The holiday was a regulated “package” within the meaning of Regulation 2(1) of the Package Travel etc. Regulations 1992. On her return to the United Kingdom Mrs X brought proceedings against the Defendant tour operator (the “organiser” and “other party to the contract”) pursuant to the Defendant’s Booking Conditions and regulation 15 of the Package Travel etc. Regulations 1992 (the Booking Conditions were intended to reflect the Defendant’s obligations under the 1992 Regulations). The essence of her claim (as presented at Trial and summarised in the first instance judgment) was “… that the sexual assault carried out by an employee of the Hotel whilst on duty, amounted to the improper performance of a contractual obligation owed by the Defendant to the Claimant pursuant to regulation 15 of the 1992 Regulations” (per HHJ McKenna, sitting as an Additional Judge of the High Court: [2016] EWHC 3090 (QB), para 16).
To read the presentation and briefing note in full, please download here: PEOPIL Presentation – X v Kuoni (May 2019)
On 10 April 2025, the Court of Appeal handed down Judgment in Re M (A Child) [2025] EWCA Civ 440, providing long awaited guidance for deciding whether and when to grant intermediary assistance to vulnerable parties in family proceedings. An intermediary is someone whose function…
This week the government announced a further consultation on proposed amendments to the Package Travel and Linked Travel Arrangements Regulations 2018; Anirudh Mandagere considers the proposals in detail and provides a link for the use of those who wish to respond to them. Alternatively, you…
The High Court handed down its judgment in Butler v Ward [2025] EWHC 877 (KB) yesterday, striking out £2.5million of the Claimant’s Schedule of Loss. Francesca O’Neill represented the Defendant surgeon (instructed by DWF LLP). The Judgment also raises interesting questions about when summary judgment applications…
Deka Chambers: 5 Norwich Street, London EC4A 1DR