Word of warning for McKenzie Friends & Co

Articles

19/03/2019

I have seen this decision reported in a number of places online and it seems to be both important and interesting, so thought I’d add something brief here.

The High Court has given much needed guidance on the duty of care owed by unqualified advisers such as McKenzie Friends. In essence they are judged by the standard that they have themselves assumed, so where a McKenzie Friend tells their client they can provide the same standard of service as a solicitor or barrister then this is the standard by which they shall be judged if a professional negligence claim is later pursued against them.

In Paul Wright v Troy Lucas (a firm) & George Rusz Mr Wright was left permanently disabled following negligently performed NHS surgery. He sought legal help from George Rusz who described himself as an experienced legal professional, operating through his company Troy Lucas which professed to be able to provide an equivalent or even superior service to any solicitor or barrister.

Mr Rusz proved to be a rather poor adviser, making a number of serious mistakes which left Mr Wright liable for adverse costs orders and caused him to under-settle his claim. Accordingly he sued Mr Rusz and Troy Lucas for professional negligence, who defended the claim on the basis there was no contract and they owed no duty of care.

The High Court dismissed these arguments, and judged the Defendants against the standard of the competent legal advisers they held themselves out to be. The claim succeeded and damages of £263,759 were awarded.

To my mind this is a triumph for unwitting consumers of legal services, and for common sense.

Latest News & Events

Coroner issues Safety Report on London junction where pedestrian suffered fatal injury

On 11 September 2022, Terence Gillard was crossing the Great West Road in Hounslow in West London when he was struck by an oncoming vehicle. He was taken to hospital and died of his injuries one week later. Although the location of his death is…

Deka Chambers Top Ranked in Legal 500 2025

We’re proud to have retained our top tier set ranking in the new edition of the Legal 500, with 131 barrister rankings across 13 practice areas. We are ranked as top tier in the field of Personal Injury, Industrial Disease and Insurance Fraud – Deka…

Tenancy Announcement: Megan Bithel-Vaughan and Julia Brechtelsbauer

Today we are pleased to welcome Megan Bithel-Vaughan and Julia Brechtelsbauer as our newest tenants, following the successful completion of their pupillages. Julia and Megan are accepting instructions across all of Deka’s practice areas in civil, criminal and family law. Please contact our clerks for…

Subscribe to our mailing list

Deka Chambers: 5 Norwich Street, London EC4A 1DR

© Deka Chambers 2024

Search

Portfolio Builder

Select the expertise that you would like to download or add to the portfolio

Download    Add to portfolio   
Portfolio
Title Type CV Email

Remove All

Download


Click here to share this shortlist.
(It will expire after 30 days.)