Judgment has been handed down by he High Court in the latest “imposter fraud” professional liability claim – and the claim was dismissed. See P&P Properties -v-OWC and Crownvent [2016] EWHC Civ 2276 (Ch).
The fraudster impersonated the true owner of an investment property in West London and instructed solicitors (D1) and reputable estate agents (D2) to sell it for him. They were duped as he had got hold of utility bills for the address and he provided a forged passport to identify himself, but asked for the sale proceeds to be sent to his bank in Dubai, from where it was never recovered. The innocent purchaser alleged breach of warranty of authority and negligence against both defendants and breach of trust against the solicitors.
The claim has been dismissed – but with permission to appeal given the interesting points which these cases throw up. These cases of imposter fraud, with a range of different and sometimes ingenious permutations, are continuing to trouble PI insurers.
Ivor Collett appeared for the Second Defendant, instructed by Mills and Reeve LLP.
In this week’s edition Linda Nelson examines how and when to serve surveillance evidence, and how and when to respond to it; and John Schmitt asks whether it’s necessary to have a claim form re-sealed if it’s been amended prior to service, and urges caution…
This week Thomas Yarrow revisits the vexed question of the use of artificial intelligence in legal research – and our intrepid reporter finds that it’s not all it’s cracked up to be. In fact the experience led him to such depths of despair that he…
This week Ben Rodgers relays two tales from the coalface, both relating to applications to resile from admissions. Readers will be interested to know that in both cases the court applied the balance of prejudice test with the result that the defendants’ applications were refused….
Deka Chambers: 5 Norwich Street, London EC4A 1DR